Creation Science

Creation Science Rebuttals

Technical Journal (TJ)

No Dark Matter in the Milky Way?

From TJ, Volume 13, Issue 1, April 1999

       

Review by Greg Neyman

© Old Earth Ministries

First Published 13 June 2006

 

      In an article from the young earth publication Technical Journal, young earth theorists Michael Oard and Jonathan Sarfati boldly proclaim in the title, "No Dark Matter Found in the Milky Way Galaxy."1  Is this true?

 

Background

 

     The young earth authors start out this article by giving some explanations about the big bang, and its problem of missing up to 90 percent of the mass of the universe.  In getting to this point, the authors state matter of factly that "Biblical creationists should oppose the 'big bang' theory, because this implies a universe 10 to 15 Ga old, which contradicts biblical chronology and implies death before the fall."  However, old earth creationists have shown that it only affects "young earth biblical chronology."  It is not contrary to an old earth interpretation of the Bible, and you can accept both billions of years and the Genesis account of creation.  The death before sin issue has also been shown to not impact any of the doctrines of the Bible, and especially the doctrine of salvation. 

     To make a long story short, dark matter was first considered back in 1933, when Swiss astrophysicist Fritz Zwicky obtained evidence that the universe contained much unseen mass.  However, this theory did not really take hold until it was refined in the 1970s.  Although dark matter has not been observed directly, its gravitational affects can be measured.

     The young earth authors appeal to two studies which shows that there is no dark matter in the disk of the Milky Way galaxy.  One study was released in the journal Astronomy and Astrophysics in 1998, and it reported that based on an analysis of the motion of 100 stars, that there was no affects of gravitational pull from the disk of the Milky Way upon these stars.  A further report, from the research thesis of a graduate student, is also mentioned.

    

Explanation

 

      While I accept these findings, that there is no dark matter in the galactic disk, one must realize that this relies upon knowing the exact mass of the galactic disk.  Since scientists have accepted this theory that there is no dark matter in the galactic disk, I can only assume that they know this value well enough to perform scientific measurements upon the gravitational pull upon these stars.

     However, that is not the main point of this article.  As you noticed from the title chosen by the young earth writers, they claim that there is no dark matter in the Milky Way galaxy.  This is not what these two references used by Oard and Sarfati claim.  Note carefully that they say there is no dark matter in the galactic disk.  The galactic disk is the center of our galaxy, which consists of many tightly packed stars.  The spiral arms of our galaxy, where earth is, is not in this galactic disk. 

     The authors correctly refer to this area as the halo.  For more on this issue, see Dark Matter Halo.  The authors refer to this halo as a "large, spherical area encircling the galaxy and containing dust, gas, and globular clusters of stars.  In dismissing the halo as containing dark matter, the authors refer to a single, solitary report about objects which were once thought to be possible chunks of dark matter, but which are now considered as dim stars.  This one report, on these isolated objects, does not disprove dark matter...it only addresses a single group of objects.  In reality, the effects of dark matter are still observed in the spiral arms of our galaxy.

     In reality, scientists are getting closer and closer to confirming the existence of dark matter.  Despite the fact that we have evidence from the gravitational effects of dark matter, young earth creationists would prefer a picture of dark matter.  We know beyond any doubt that there is an unseen mass affecting the gravitational forces upon objects in our galaxy.  Until we take an actual photo, these reports will have to do.

 

'Missing' Dark Matter Is Really There

Team Maps Dark Matter In Startling Detail

Dark Matter Galaxy Identified

Astrophysicists Detect Cosmic Shear, Evidence of Dark Matter

Seeing The Invisible

Chandra Probes Nature of Dark Matter

Dark Matter (Wikipedia)

Cold Dark Matter (Wikipedia)

Dark Matter Halo (Wikipedia)

 

     Many more links are available, but these should be enough to demonstrate some of the evidence for dark matter.

(NOTE:  On 21 August 2006, a team of scientists announced the best discovery yet of the existence of dark matter.  You can read about the news release in this CNN.COM article.

 

Conclusion

 

     This article boldly proclaimed that the Milky Way galaxy has no dark matter, and the authors based this claim on the absence of dark matter in the galactic disk (core), a claim which is accepted by scientists.  However, the claim that the rest of the galaxy does not have dark matter is only based on a solitary claim about one specific set of objects.  In reality, the existence of dark matter in our galaxy, and in other galaxies, is an established fact due to the gravitational effects of the dark matter.  We know the matter is there...its effects can be measured.  However, we cannot take a picture of it, which is the only proof that most young earth creationists would accept.      

1  Michael Oard, Jonathan Sarfati, No dark matter found in the Milky Way Galaxy, TJ 13(1): April 1999.  Available online at answersingenesis.org/tj/v13/i1/milky_way.asp

 


 

    If you are not a Christian, and you have been holding out on making a decision for Christ because the Church always preached a message that was contrary to what you saw in the scientific world, then rest assured that the Bible is the inerrant Word of God, and you can believe in Christ and receive salvation, while still believing in an old earth.  Click here for more.

 

    Are you a Christian who believes in young earth creationism?  Now that we have shown the many difficulties of the young earth creation science model in this and many other articles, how does this impact your Christian life?  If you are a young earth creationism believer, click here.

 

 

Print-Friendly PDF Version

Technical Journal Home

More Michael Oard Rebuttals

More Jonathan Sarfati Rebuttals

 

Related Articles

Astronomy Articles

 

 

To learn more about old earth creationism, see Old Earth Belief, or check out the article Can You Be A Christian and Believe in an Old Earth?  

 Feel free to check out more of this website.  Our goal is to provide rebuttals to the bad science behind young earth creationism, and honor God by properly presenting His creation.